A decade after the UK entered into a hasty referendum that polarised the nation and unleashed chaos, a warning comes from across the Irish Sea: it may occur once more.
Policymakers and citizens sleepwalked into Brexit and the same may happen with a national vote on a unified Ireland, triggering upheavals for which no one is ready.
That represents the warning from two prominent commentators from each side of the Irish border who have joined forces to scrutinise the advantages and disadvantages of Northern Ireland exiting the UK to create a fresh nation with the Republic of Ireland.
Administrative Institutions Unprepared
The author and columnist and The Northern Ireland editor, have concluded that the administrative systems in Ireland and Britain are woefully unready for a potentially fraught and seismic referendum.
"The lesson of Brexit hasn't been learned, which is that stuff can emerge unexpectedly and can gather momentum swiftly," O’Toole stated. "I would suggest that the governmental framework of our islands remains very unstable."
Released Volume Seeks to Provoke Discussion
The team have analysed the governmental, financial and cultural rationales for any governmental shift in a book, The Case For and Against Unification, published by the Dublin-based Royal Irish Academy.
They seek to provoke discussion on the issue with a series of lectures that will lead them to Westminster early next month.
"What troubles everybody, or ought to concern everybody, is the Brexit vote of 2016," said the analyst.
"We should prevent a referendum on a binary, unclear proposal whose results have not been clarified because then you land with an highly divided society where people who have lost are unable to accept defeat and the people who have won are uncertain exactly what it is that they have won."
Legal Framework
Under the Belfast Agreement, the Northern Ireland government minister is obliged to schedule a public vote on Irish unification if it appears likely that a most voters would support.
Sinn Féin and other pro-unification groups say this point is imminent, and a group named pro-unification advocates has garnered backing, but both governments and unionists downplay the prospect, making it uncertain whether or when there might be a national vote.
Absence of Serious Debate
Partisan language for and against unification has obscured the absence of substantive discussion, said the journalist.
"Individuals are often supportive or opposed the idea but the concrete planning which may surpass that to make it possible is mostly absent. A great deal has gone on in academia but hardly any government figures or advocates are willing to participate even with the basics. As an example, what type of nation would you want? Unitary? Decentralised?"
Book's Approach
In the publication, no writer endorses unity or the existing arrangement. Both writes two essays that aim for impartiality in detailing the rationale for a united Ireland and the case opposing it, assembling financial and social data, historical precedents and constitutional models.
Discussions cover national emblems, taxes, healthcare systems, pensions, sovereign debt obligations and the threat of pro-UK militancy. The objective is to educate and encourage discussion.
"There's huge interest in the issue but there is still lacking a debate," stated O’Toole. "Discussion suggests an acceptance of the concept that there might be good arguments on either side."
Dual Referendums
A public vote in Northern Ireland would also trigger one in the republic, where citizens claim they prefer unification but oppose paying higher taxes or adopting a alternative symbol to recognise pro-UK communities' UK heritage.
"Policymakers in Ireland does need to work out what the proposal from pro-unification movements is beyond just saying: 'We want a unified Ireland and we love you'," said the commentator.
Probability of Referendum
The journalist believes a referendum in his generation is possible and that it may take place abruptly. "It is possible just a irresponsible or a bad or a negligent official who declares: 'Let us proceed and settle the matter.'"
Both nationalists and unionists have credible, justified perspectives, he commented. "One side will prevail on this issue and somebody will in the end not succeed but each side has got important lessons to gain from the other's arguments."
Call for More Extensive Dialogue
Westminster must join the dialogue, stated the analyst. "This is about Britain. It is a UK matter as much as it is an Irish question."